各位大侠,前一阵子,本人投了一篇SCI文章,三个审稿人,一个拒稿,意见比较尖锐,基本上持否定态度。另外两个是小修。主编给了一个大修。这样的情况,该如何修改?修改后还会给第一个审稿人看吗?
第一个审稿人:The quality of the paper was so poor. It could not been accepted and little information could be gained from the text. 还列了一大堆意见。
第二个审稿人: In general, this Manuscript has an attractive scientific topic and it is appropriate to be published in this journal. I have just a few minor suggestions to improve the Manuscript.
第三个审稿人:This manuscript***,and provided some useful information. However, some points are unclear and need further clarification. 返回小木虫查看更多
|